In academics, there is a well-established reward system for getting your work published in peer-reviewed journals. Whether or you not get hired, get money to do research, get to keep your job i. After years of academic indoctrination and soaking up academic values, it was pretty depressing, in some ways, to learn having peer-reviewed publications no longer mattered.
One of the greatest shocks when I started working in industry was the realization that the peer-reviewed paper, the most valuable form of currency in the academic world, was valued so little. In academics, there is a well-established reward system for getting your work published in peer-reviewed journals.
Whether or you not get hired, get money to do research, get to keep your job i. Community colleges are an exception to this, there it's your teaching abilities that matter, not your publications. After years of academic indoctrination and soaking up academic values, it was pretty depressing, in some ways, to learn having peer-reviewed publications no longer mattered.
In the commercial software world, peer-review has no or little value. Many people don't know what it is, and if they do know, they don't care. The business people seem to think that scientific papers are written by ghost-writers and the software engineers think they're written by people from marketing.
You mean, a white paper and a peer-reviewed scientific publication aren't the same thing? Just to set the record straight, white papers are Difference between research white paper publications that serve to explain the technology used in a product.
Peer-reviewed publications are scientific articles that must be read and accepted by other scientists. Peer review is not a perfect system, but it does have meaning, at least to other scientists.
I also learned that there are some very good reasons why many companies don't bother with the peer-review system. Mostly, there aren't many incentives for software companies to publish peer-reviewed papers. These papers take an incredible amount of time to write and revise.
For a business, the price of that time is often too high and the return on the investment is too low. A white paper, which doesn't require peer-review, can be written and distributed at a much lower cost and in much less time.
So, I'm quite happy that now, thanks to BPR3, if we blog about peer-reviewed research, we have some new icons that we can use to identify what's what. If you are a reader, look for this icon to find out if a post is about peer-reviewed research. If you are a blogger, you can use this icon to let your readers know that you're writing about research work that was strong enough to withstand review.
The guidelines and icons are here. Tags Log in to post comments More like this Build a better peer-review icon for the blogosphere Bloggers for Peer-Reviewed Research Reporting has announced a contest to design an icon to identify serious blog posts discussing peer-reviewed research.
Anyone will be able to use the icon on their blog posts whenever the post is a serious commentary about a paper published in a peer-reviewed… BPR3. The new web site has just gone live. Set your bookmarks to researchblogging. Anyone can use these icons to show when they're making a serious post about peer-… What is peer review, anyway?
Over at BPR3, a reader brought up an interesting question about the nature of peer-reviewed research, which I thought was relevant to our readers here as well. I'm reposting my entire response below. The system of peer review, the bulwark of academic publishing, has served scholars for centuries.
Log in to post comments By dave X not verified on 29 Oct permalink Another "problem" with accepting peer-review in industry is the business secrecy. From my experience, it just seems incomprehensible for industry people to have anyone outside the company reading through internal unpublished research material to say if it has any value and future prospects.
It's like a marketing suicide. The reason is that their goals are different economic profit vs pure knowledge. Log in to post comments By Harris not verified on 29 Oct permalink dave X• Categorized under Career & Education | Difference Between a White Paper and a Case Study White Paper vs Case Study There are several significant differences between a White Paper and a Case study when it comes to the tone, objectives, audience, subject-matter, and directness of each document.
In an opinion paper, you will focus on a topic about which you have personal thoughts, beliefs, or tranceformingnlp.com goal is to persuade your reader that your position on this topic is the best one. You won’t accomplish that goal with a rant or diatribe. Instead, you will need to support your claim with facts, statistics, real-life examples or published research .
Oct 29, · I just think it’s important for people to know that there is a difference between the kinds of publications and the criteria that are used for review.
(or abstract white papers), while. What is the Difference Between a Research Paper and an Essay? Research Paper Researching and expressing other’s points of view on a topic, as well as incorporating your paper.
Thought is given to the purpose of the writing and what type of essay it is. The. In , extensive research for my book White Papers For Dummies showed that the average fee for a text-only white paper was $4, Most B2B marketers expect to pay between $5, and $7, for an experienced white paper writer.
What's the difference between a report and a research paper? Toggle menu visibility.
Ask Another Question. This site is amazing, it helped to receive a 98 on a research paper would recommend it if you are anywhere confused about writing a research paper.
by Sergio Cristian Ruiz on Jul 18,